Want to Find the REAL Story? Ignore Your Instincts

Guys. I’ve fallen in love with this essay by Emily Ruskovich. It so beautifully captures the author’s process of how stories evolve, how they morph from a single image, feeling, or idea into a full-fledged story—if we just let it lead us to where it wants to go. I hope it inspires you as much as it did me.

For me, so much of writing is chasing feelings I don’t understand. Sometimes the feelings mingle with memory, and sometimes they don’t. Paying attention to these feelings, which can arise at any time, is crucial.

Sometimes, at first, I chase the feeling too fast. I make an easy story out of it, using instincts I have developed as a fiction writer. The story is neat. Its climax is exciting. A great deal is at stake. But usually, this first story is not the real story. It’s just a structure I build quickly in my mind to house the original feeling. And the real story is the one I find only by actively not forming a story out of it, only by actively ignoring my instincts. Instead, I allow images to gather in my imagination in this strange way that is very dif- ficult for me to describe. These images might gather over the course of a day, or over several years. The images feed the feeling until, finally, the feeling is whole enough for me to capture it inside of a scene. And then it happens fast.

story inspiration, short story, writing process how do i write a story

It’s as if fiction is this parallel world that is real and living all the time, and these feelings that authors get are simply tiny collisions of our world and the other. It always feels like an accident to me, when I dip into that other world, because I don’t know the rules of how these worlds overlap, and I can’t sense their orbits.

This is not a metaphor; this is actually what it feels like when I write. A few days ago, my cat licked a mosquito off a cold window, and immediately I felt the first flicker of a story. Why? I don’t know. A few days before that, my brother and I scooped with an old coffee can a gelatinous sac of bullfrog eggs out of a grassy ditch, and I felt it then, too, as if I’d accidentally scooped into that can a portal to that other world.

Again, this isn’t a metaphor. It’s actually how it feels. Some images catch hold and linger. They are imbued with irrational meaning. They are the souls of stories I haven’t yet found.

A few summers ago, walking through a very small town, my mother pointed to an old farmhouse and told me about a relative of hers who once lived there. When he was a baby, his father put him out on the porch in the winter, hoping the baby would freeze to death. The story made me very sad for my relative, and angry at the cruelty of his father. I began to imagine that someone walking by the house looked in and saw the baby on the frozen porch, and I imagined the stranger breaking the window with a rock, climbing in, and rescuing the child.

This was the first story, the easy one, partly because it was so close to the real story, and  partly because the emotions were exact – sadness for the baby boy, fury and disgust for
the father, love for the stranger. It was compelling, and it made me feel.

But it was not the real story. The real story began to rise in me the farther we walked away from that house, talking about other things. If the light that afternoon had been a little different, if the dust hadn’t tasted in the air the way it did, if we had stopped for a cup of coffee or even just to tie a shoe – it’s likely the story would have stopped at its own trueness. But as it was, it grew. Suddenly, I saw the porch in my mind, and it was completely different from the real porch, the one I’d seen just minutes ago. And locked inside of it was not my relative, but a little girl I’d never known, ten years old with dirty-blonde hair and a bright and cruel face, a tight, twitching mouth.

She was standing in the middle of that porch that was built out of windows. This was her punishment for something (what?) terrible that she had done, to stand out here in the cold, locked out of the house and also out of the out-of-doors, in the frozen in-
between space that was the covered porch. The windows were framed with frost. The locked door behind her was blue. I saw the stale, wicker chair beside her. I could smell its frozen cushion. On the ground, a cup of water, as if her father could assuage his guilt by reminding himself he had given her that. The girl wore a dress. She could have put on her coat, which was wadded up beneath that wicker chair, but she did not, though her bare arms were covered in goosebumps. She stood perfectly straight in the middle of the porch. And what she was wasn’t sad – she was wildly glad. She relished her own hunger; she devoured that cold. Her breath was bright and beautiful and scary.

And, suddenly, it wasn’t her father who had put her there but her older brother, a teenager, fed up and hardworking and in charge, much older than his sister but not half as
smart. Inside, he is secretly pained by having locked his little sister on the winter porch to punish her. He feels tired and guilty and half-panicked at what he’s done and what he can’t quite decide to undo, though it would be the simplest thing in the world, to just unlock that door and let her win. He’s looking through the curtain of a different window, seeing the passersby, his neighbors, glance at his poor sister, locked out
in the cold, and he is punished by their glances, by their shame of him.

And suddenly, it’s not the girl who is being punished by her brother, and it’s not her brother who is being punished by the glances of the passersby; it is the passersby themselves who are being punished by the girl. They glance up at those windows and see her staring out at them, see her gathering the pity from their eyes until what’s left in them is only their own shame, as if they, somehow, are to blame for the abuse she is enduring so bravely, in total silence, in total stillness, hands clasped elegantly in front of her. And they know that she is making a display of herself, but they are wrong about why: They think she stands that way, in pained grace, because she is trying to preserve her dignity. They think she wants to appear to the world as strong and brave for their sakes. And such striving makes her even more pitiable in their eyes, her stern innocence a terrible shock in the winter light. Should they go knock on the door? Chastise whomever has done this to her? Should they call the police? Should they spare the girl by pretending they haven’t seen and just hope, pray, that it will end soon for her? It is terrible, the indecision and the shame.

The girl knows all this, of course, and doesn’t mind the cold because of what she knows. She is glad for this singular chance to stand in this perfect glass case, like a museum display, and exhibit to the world the stupidity of her brother and the culmination of all the injustices inflicted upon her beautiful self.

And she triumphs; to the passersby, the girl becomes more than herself, a feeling they carry into their own warm houses. For some of them, she is a memory of having long ago endured pain inflicted by adults; for others, she is the memory of having just yesterday inflicted that pain upon a child. She is guilt; she is blame. She is a trapped and frozen breath that chills her brother to his core and lasts in him forever.

All of this is only an instant, something I felt over the course of a single summer walk beside my mom. And yet this instant has stayed inside of me for two years now, and nothing has ever come of it except this essay, an answer to a question: What is writing like?

Maybe there is nothing more to this story. Maybe this is it.

Or maybe one day she’ll wake up inside of me, suddenly furious to discover that she has been used as an example. I will be there on the sidewalk, and she will look out, and I will see her blame me for what I’ve done to her story, for my cold exploitation of her pain. Suddenly, she will look down at the floor, where the cup of water has frozen solid after all this time. And she will bend down, bang that cup against the floorboards until that cylinder of ice slides out. Then she will pick the ice up, wrap it in the coat she removes from beneath that wicker chair, and bang it against every window, breaking them all.

Then, like fiction itself, she’ll climb out, down into her yard, face me for an instant, and turn away.

Emily Ruskovich’s piece is part of The Compact Guide To Short Story Writing, which features 14 essays on the craft of short story writing. The guide explores crafting killer beginnings and endings, idea formation, character development and more all via the relatively small number of pages a short story is limited to—indeed, a unique challenge but also an opportunity to take some interesting storytelling risks. Whether you write short stories, novels, screenplays, picture books, or any other form of narrative writing, this guide is a goldmine of helpful gems. 

About BECCA PUGLISI

Becca Puglisi is an international speaker, writing coach, and bestselling author of The Emotion Thesaurus and its sequels. Her books are available in five languages, are sourced by US universities, and are used by novelists, screenwriters, editors, and psychologists around the world. She is passionate about learning and sharing her knowledge with others through her Writers Helping Writers blog and via One Stop For Writers—a powerhouse online library created to help writers elevate their storytelling. You can find Becca online at both of these spots, as well as on Facebook and Twitter.
This entry was posted in Short Stories, Uncategorized, Writing Craft. Bookmark the permalink.

20 Responses to Want to Find the REAL Story? Ignore Your Instincts

  1. Gina says:

    Thanks for this post! I think it was very insightful, I really enjoyed reading it.

  2. Pingback: Top Picks Thursday! For Writers & Readers 08-31-2017 | The Author Chronicles

  3. Pingback: Writing Links…8/28/17 – Where Genres Collide

  4. Great story. I often go through versions of a story until I hit the right place for the story.

  5. Isn’t it amazing how one idea or image spur others? I was so enthralled reading this, I wish it was a real story. Indeed, this is how the writing process works some days. One reason I am a firm believer in brainstorming when stuck. You never know what new ideas will come out of it.

  6. :Donna says:

    Wow. I so enjoyed reading this, Becca. It really does describe how stories (and ideas, in general) grow and morph. It often begins with an image, an instant, an anecdote and when the right ones strike, we know there’s SOMEthing there. Sometimes we leave them be and store them away or forget them. Sometimes we allow our minds to continue going down that creative road and allow the development and brainstorming. Sometimes the idea visits us like an occasional friend, or annoying neighbor, and there’s usually some form of growth, again and again. I know, for me, I always feel such a sense of joy when I discover another piece of the puzzle and it fits! 😀

    • It’s funny because my process doesn’t work like this AT ALL. When a new idea comes along, I just grab it and start working. It never occurred to me to let the IDEA simmer and see how it might change and grow, and I’m looking forward to incorporating more of this in the future.

  7. Lynnette Jalufka says:

    Thanks for the post. It describes exactly how I write.

  8. Jack Tyler says:

    I found this essay to be quite the hat trick, powerful, entertaining, and informative. I don’t want to drop an ad on your blog, so feel free to delete this once you’ve read it. I’m just here to inform you that I’ve reblogged this at https://jackshideout.blogspot.com/
    If you would like anything changed or removed, drop a quick line, and it will be done.

  9. I loved this post. I think as writers, it is easy for our instinct to kick in and immediately “mine” a special moment for a story, to clinically dissect that spark when it speaks, “Pay attention, there’s magic here.” But you are absolutely right–often if we let the moment settle and not be in such a hurry to dig for the story, epiphanies come in layers. The story idea has time to mature, and the result is being able to work with something that contains much more depth than the original idea.

    This is such an accurate account of what it is like for me when an idea comes, but I think I don’t always let the story reveal itself to me naturally. I’m going to try more to be patient and let it happen rather than allow excitement to force it. Thanks so much for this post. 🙂

  10. I absolutely adore this piece because it is NOT a list of “do this, then do that” — we creatives need more than rote tips that fail us all. Thanks, Becca, for your bravery.

    • I admit that I’m a step-by-step writer. I like to know, on a practical level, how to incorporate new information and devices. But the beauty of this method, imo, is that it just…flows. It’s something I know I could use more during the idea generating part of the process.

  11. Andreas says:

    Umm… Come again?

    How is ignoring your instincts going to be a help in finding the real story?

    Because when I read this page because the page topic led me to believe I would get writing advice, I found that I had to sit through a short story instead.

    If the whole book is filled with “valuable advice” like this (meaning the chapter titles promise advice that we never get to actually receive because the writer instead decides to tell anecdotes), then that’s one book of “writing advice” I`ll happily skip.

    Or was that piece just an example of modern “advice” where you have to sit through lengthy preamble (more than 1.500 words) and somewhere within is hidden a “gem” of advice, and that “gem” is not even explicitly stated, but only vaguely implied?
    Some writers like to rationalize behavior like that with “I want my readers to pay attention to what I’m writing!”. But most readers really don’t like being lured to a website with the promise of finding valuable advice, but when they arrive, they find that they have to read somebody clearing his head in a lengthy essay of fiction instead, and then never even delivers upon the promised advice.

    I am sorry if I sound negative. But if a post title promises certain informations, then that post really should deliver upon that promise. NOT impressed. But no doubt, being a professional, you`ll be grateful for my honest feedback, right?

    • Andreas, I’m sorry that the content of this post didn’t speak to you. Every writer’s process is different, which is why I wanted to share this post, to show that by ignoring our typical instinct to grab onto an initial story idea and run with it, we can end up with a better, more interesting story by letting it brew and evolve into something different and “truer” than we first imagined. As such, I thought the title accurately expressed what to expect from the post. This viewpoint on exploring story ideas is one I had never considered before; I could see value in it for myself and so wanted to share it. But not every process, post, or idea is for everyone. Thank you for your honest feedback.

      • Andreas says:

        Hello Becca,

        I understand (generally) where you come from.

        But WHERE in your long post is your advice detailed and explained?

        Could you cut and paste the passage, please?

        Because I can’t find it. I look at your long post, yet all I can see is a long (and, to me, to be quite frankly, very dull) anecdote about some girl that doesn’t seem to have anything to do with the advice that your post title pretends this post would have to do with.

        C`mon, Becca. You CAN do better than this.

        • We publish different kinds of posts here. Some contain step-by-step information for how to apply information, some are inspirational/keep-your-head-up notes, and others, like this, are examples of how writers process and explore their ideas and methods. The reason I chose to post this author’s process was because it could turn on a light bulb for someone who may not have considered this route to a story. It’s also likely that the author pursues her story ideas through a more organic and unstructured method; as such, there is no Step 1, Step 2, Step 3, etc. for her to share. If this doesn’t appeal to you, that’s ok. We’re all different, with varying tastes and styles. For me, that’s part of what makes the writing community such a beautiful place to be.

  12. Sheri Levy says:

    This was a fun read. I could relate to the thinking process.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *