What Makes Up Fantasy As A Genre?
If you want to write a fantasy novel, it pays to understand what goes into this fascinating genre. Fantasy conventions can vary widely, but there are some common elements we can find. Here’s a few key conventions of fantasy novels that I learned writing my own … Ready? Let’s go!
1) Magic
Magic can be a fundamental element of fantasy novels. It is often used by characters to achieve extraordinary feats or interact with the supernatural. One of the top things to remember here is to ensure your magic systems have limitations. If there are no constraints to your magic system, then this can impact the potential conflict of your story. This is where Brandon Sanderson’s 3 Laws For Magic Systems can really help.
2) Fantastic Creatures
Where there’s magic, there’s also monsters. But fantasy novels often feature mythical creatures that are not necessarily evil too. Dragons, elves, hobbits, witches, centaurs, unicorns, gigantic sea serpents, sandworms… they can be anything you like. The sky really is the limit!
3) Hero’s Journey
The Hero’s Journey is a classic plotting archetype, charting a protagonist’s growth from ‘zero to hero’. Many fantasy stories follow the classic hero’s journey, where a protagonist embarks on an adventure, faces challenges, and ultimately undergoes personal growth. Such fantasy novels as Harry Potter, Dune and even my own, The Coven, follow this archetype.
4) Storyworld
Traditional fantasy worlds are often inspired by medieval settings, featuring castles, knights, and kingdoms, creating a sense of timelessness and wonder. However, there’s such a thing as urban fantasy too that does the opposite. Instead of being ‘ye olde’, it might take place in our own world, with a secret underworld of magical people. In short, storyworld can be anything you want … as long as you start as you mean to go on!
5) Epic Battles
Epic battles between forces of good and evil are a common theme in fantasy. Such battles often showcasing bravery, sacrifice, and the triumph of good over evil. A good example here would be Marvel’s Avengers: Endgame which has a fantastic end battle that does all these things.
6) Quests
Quests can be a staple of fantasy literature. The Hero’s Journey (as per #3 on this list) is one large quest in which characters set out on a journey to accomplish a specific goal, facing obstacles and adversaries along the way.
7) Prophecy
Prophecies and foretold destinies play a significant role in many fantasy stories. These prophecies then shape the actions of characters and drive the plot forward. In The Coven, ‘The Proclamation of The Elementals’ starts the book:
“We are all kernels in the earth. We are baptised by fire; fed by the water of life, powered by air. To us, we call The One: connect us through the chain of being and bring us liberation from the ties that bind us.”
This prophecy tells of an all-powerful witch The Elementals call ‘The One’. In this storyworld, Elemental witches have the power of one of the four elements: air, water, fire or earth … but The One has ALL four elements. As the prophecy foretells, The One is powerful enough to free all witches around the world.
8) Parallel Worlds
Fantasy often explores the idea of parallel worlds or alternate realities. In The Coven the world is almost the same as ours … except that up to 50% of women have magic. The leaders of the world don’t like this one bit, especially the President of The United States, Michael Hopkins. He decrees that witches must be locked up for their own safety as well as non-magical peoples’.
I watched a lot of political rallies when I was writing The Coven. I really wanted to make the politics of my parallel world believable, but worried about Hopkins being too jingoistic. Yet every time I sent these scenes off to my editor or beta readers, it always came back with: ‘Still not as bad as the REAL guy!’ That was surprising.
9) Lore and Mythology
Fantasy worlds are rich in lore, mythology, and history, providing depth and context to the setting and characters. I am a big fan of ‘The Power of Three’ in writing. When things come in threes in literature, it’s believed they can be more satisfying, more effective and/or more memorable, than other numbers of things.
I enacted The Power of Three with my witches in The Coven. The ‘Triumvirate’ refers not only to witchcraft generally – Mother, Maiden, Crone – but also the witches themselves.
The vast majority are Kitchen Witches, who don’t have innate magic of their own. Instead they have spell books, cauldrons, poppets, family spells etc rather like our own reality.
Where it changes are the other two types of witches. About 5-8% of witches are Crystal Witches. They do have innate magic in their veins, but can only access it with crystals (as their names suggest). The remaining 2% are The Elemental witches (mentioned in #7).
10) Themes of Good vs. Evil
Fantasy frequently explores themes of morality, ethics, and the battle between light and darkness. Whilst the story may deal with UNreal settings, creatures, magic etc, it may be about very real issues. These UNreal things can offer insights into human nature and society. As The Sun newspaper said of The Coven: ‘A scarily real take on society today … buckle up for a battle like no other’.
Got any questions about writing fantasy? I’m very happy to answer … leave them in the comments and I will get back to you.
Good Luck With Your Own Fantasy Novels!
Lucy V. Hay is a script editor, author and blogger who helps writers. She’s been the script editor and advisor on numerous UK features and shorts & has also been a script reader for 20 years, providing coverage for indie prodcos, investors, screen agencies, producers, directors and individual writers. She’s also an author, publishing as both LV Hay and Lizzie Fry. Lizzie’s latest, a serial killer thriller titled The Good Mother is out now with Joffe Books, with her sixth thriller out in 2024. Lucy’s site at www.bang2write.com has appeared in Top 100 round-ups for Writer’s Digest & The Write Life, as well as a UK Blog Awards Finalist and Feedspot’s #1 Screenwriting blog in the UK (ninth in the world.). She is also the author of the bestselling non-fiction book, Writing & Selling Thriller Screenplays: From TV Pilot To Feature Film (Creative Essentials), which she updated for the streaming age for its tenth anniversary in 2023.
Michael Dunne says
Timely words as I look to get back into my own stories (after spending all my “spare” time editing other authors’ books). I know there are two things on this list I need to cement in my fantasy novel(s): a believable set of rules for my magic system and a firmer grasp of the story’s geography. Every time I get into world building, I fall down the “What’s the best map rendering tool” rabbit hole!
Other than that, a question for you is: How does one avoid falling prey to tropes while staying true to the fantasy genre’s key themes and familiar aspects readers will expect to find in the story? It seems a fine line between fantasy content expectations and tropes. Thoughts?
Thank you!
Lucy V says
Hi Michael, apologies for the delay in getting back to you – I was travelling then teaching all weekend, been a busy time here!
When it comes to tropes, you don’t want to avoid them necessarily. It’s a common misconception that tropes are automatically bad, but they’re not. Tropes are just recurrent ideas you see in stories – for example, The Hero’s Journey is both a plotting archetype *and* a trope of the fantasy genre. So is good vs evil.
This means readers LOVE tropes, they hate clichés. Tropes become clichéd when they’re used too much – nothing more, nothing less. How tropes become clichéd can depend, which is why do many writers swear off them … but ironically a genre with NO tropes whatsoever will be dissatisfying and boring.
So my advice is EMBRACE TROPES – just research them to avoid the overly cliched ones. Sites like TVTropes and Tropedia are great places to start. You can also find an article about tropes if you click my name on this comment. Good luck!
Michael says
Absolutely no worries on the delay! I feel your pain 🙂
Thank you so much for the additional guidance and I’ll definitely read your dope on tropes 😉
V.M. Sang says
A timely reminder of what readers expect in a fantasy novel. I recently had to rewrite parts of my fantasy prequel to my Wolves of Vimar series as I realised there was no magic in it, nor mythical beasts.
Lucy V says
Yup, genre markers are so key and we’ve all been there when it comes to forgetting them! Good luck with your projects 😀
MINDY ALYSE WEISS says
Thanks so much for this awesome list, Lucy! I usually write humorous contemporary middle grade, but attempted two fantasy MGs a while back that I haven’t given a lot of attention to lately. You’re inspiring me to rescue one of them soon. 🙂
Lucy V says
Love that! Good luck with it, Mindy
ANGELA ACKERMAN says
Great review of all the deliciousness readers expect to see in fantasy novels, Lucy! It’s been awhile since I read this genre, and your post is making me think about shaking up the TBR pile. 🙂
Lucy V says
Thanks Angela, glad you enjoyed the article and found it inspiring for your TBR shake up!