Hey, wonderful writerly people! It’s time for our monthly critique contest! This month, we have a HUGE prize!
3 winners will receive feedback on 20 pages from a professional editor. So exciting!
3 winners will receive feedback on 20 pages from a professional editor. So exciting!
This contest is closed. Please try again next month. If you’d like to be notified when the next one goes live, consider subscribing to the blog (in the sidebar).
If you’re working on a story and would like some objective feedback, please leave a comment. Any comment :). As long as the email address associated with your WordPress account/comment profile is up-to-date, I’ll be able to contact you if you’re a lucky winner. Please know that if I’m unable to get in touch with you through that address, you’ll have to forfeit your win.
Here’s the editor you’ll be working with:
Stuart Wakefield
With 26 years in theatre, broadcast media, and coaching under my belt, I have a visceral understanding of what makes stories work, and I love to share that with others because the world of storytelling is like the ocean: deep, mysterious, and a little scary to those who don’t know how to navigate it. With so much left to luck and timing, it’s my life’s mission to give great books the best chance of getting into readers’ hands. I particularly love to coach Romance, Commercial Women’s Fiction, YA, New Adult, and Contemporary Fiction.
As a writer myself, I have an MA (Distinction) in Professional Writing, and my debut novel, Body of Water, was one of ten books long-listed for the Polari First Book Prize. My latest novel, Behind the Seams, was a 2021 BookLife Fiction Prize Contest semi finalist.
I’m an Author Accelerator Certified Book Coach, a proud Partner Member of the Alliance of Independent Authors, and I was recognised as one of the top book coaches by Coach Foundation: https://coachfoundation.com/blog/top-book-coaches/ You can find my website, blog, and free self-editing cheat sheet right here: https://linktr.ee/thebookcoach
Contest Guidelines
- Please be sure your first 20 pages are ready to go so Stuart can critique them before next month’s contest rolls around. A4 paper size (you can find this in Word settings), 1-inch margins, double-spaced, and 12pt Times New Roman font. Feedback will consist of in-line comments concerning what’s not working and what is.
- You’ll need to have a synopsis ready (a rough one is fine) so Stuart can make sure his feedback is in context.
- This contest only runs for 24 hours, start to finish, so get your comment in there!
Three commenters’ names will be randomly drawn and posted tomorrow morning. If you win, I’ll contact you with information about sending it to me. Then, I’ll forward it to our amazing editor for feedback.
We run this contest on a monthly basis, so if you’d like to be notified when the next opportunity comes around, consider subscribing to our blog (see the right-hand sidebar).
Good luck! I can’t wait to see who the winners will be. 🙂
Save the Date!
Becca will be back to critique first pages next month, but in the meantime, she wanted you all to know about an upcoming opportunity to grow in your craft. On January 28th at 2pm EST, she’ll be presenting an online webinar on Using Character Emotion to Wow Readers. Romance Writers Online are opening this event up to everyone, and registration is live. Use this link to learn more about this webinar or to save yourself a seat!
PS: If you want to amp up your first page, grab our helpful First Pages checklist from One Stop for Writers. And for more instruction on these important opening elements, see this Mother Lode of First Page Resources.
Mindy loves giving back to the writing community. She’s a founding member and Administrator on the From the Mixed-Up Files…of Middle-Grade Authors blog, an SCBWI volunteer, and host of the PBParty chats, New Draft Challenge & Critique Train, and annual contest. She writes middle grade novels and picture books filled with humor, heart, and hope and is represented by Joyce Sweeney.
Ali Ammoura says
This is a great opportunity. Thank you! Count me in!
MINDY ALYSE WEISS says
Hi Ali,
Thanks for your interest in our Phenomenal First Page Contest! Stuart was our amazing guest editor last month, and winners were chosen about 24 hours after this contest went live. Our next contest will be tomorrow, February 16. I hope you’ll come back and enter for a chance to win that one!
If you subscribe to the Writers Helping Writers blog on the upper right side of the page, you’ll receive it via e-mail (which is helpful). Another way to receive posts via e-mail is to click ‘Notify me of new posts by email’ which shows up under the comment box while replying. You can also hop over to our site and click ‘blog’ to see our most recent posts.
Brian Dale Pope says
Count me in!
MINDY ALYSE WEISS says
A huge thank you to Stuart for these amazing prizes! And thank you all for hopping over to Writers Helping Writers to enter. The lucky winners are:
Julee Nicklaus
Amanda I
Glenda Warburton
I’ll send the three of you an e-mail with instructions. Congrats!
Dee Hofmann says
I would appreciate a professional edit of my first twenty. Thanks!
Lisa Connors says
I would love the feedback on my women’s fiction.
Danna Zeiger says
I could really use this, thanks so much!
Candice Robinson-Horejsi says
Oh, I would love this!
Jessica Federle says
Awesome opportunity! The tips linked to are helpful too.
Teresa Garcia Lowe says
I would love the opportunity to take part! Looking forward to instructions on next steps!
Angie McCullagh says
Oh my gosh, thank you for offering this opportunity! I would love to be considered and have my first 20 pages ready (Plus a synopsis).
Becky says
Wow! This would be an incredible opportunity!!
Karen Harding says
My firs introduction to Angela & Becca’s resource material came from a fellow writer. The Emotion Thesaurus to this day remains one of my treasured resource books. It encourages an active voice and has been invaluable as my go-to reference. I have a wealth of resource material, but the Emotion Thesuarus has gotten the most use to date.
Ginger Kenney says
Thank you for this opportunity! I’d love to have Stuart’s critique, so… fingers crossed!
Alexandria Taylor says
I would love this opportunity!
Deborah says
All your posts are worth reading. Thanks for helping writers reach readers, and for feedback and critiques.
Cecilia says
Thank you for this wonderful opportunity Angela and Stuart!
Victoria Waddle says
I would love feedback on my first pages. Thank you for providing this opportunity!
Lora Doncea says
Oh, I would LOVE to win this! I need a professional male to critique my suspense novel, and I welcome all feedback. I hope I get picked!! 🙂
Tara Henderson says
A great learning opportunity. Thanks!
Deena Graves says
This is such a great opportunity! Thank you. First pages are not for the faint of heart.
Laurie Wood says
Thank you for this amazing opportunity! I have 20 pages and a synopsis all ready to go and would love the chance for feedback.
Cecilia Bamberg says
I know my first pages need a boost and would love some feedback. Thanks for this opportunity.
Delia Keymel says
Great opportunity. Hope my pages are chosen.
Judy L Mohr says
This is such an amazing opportunity. Thank you for hosting this. And thank you to Stuart Wakefield for his generosity.
Cathy Hendrix says
I would be over the moon if Mr. Wakefield could critique my first 20 pages!
Robin Wiesneth says
I’d love feedback on my novel! Good lucknto everyone 🙂
Trischa Buhler says
What a great opportunity! I’ll definitely come back to try again if I don’t win this month!
Diane Rinella says
I’ve never entered one of these, but I think now is a great time. Thanks for always being so supportive!
Randy Landenberger says
Thank you for the opportunity! Confused about the WordPress email. I created a profile, put in my ‘normal’ email. WordPress shows a possible different profile name/adress? Eg. @randlscott on WordPress.org. I’m not using that. Should I?
Marie Powell says
Glad to see this happening! Thanks for the information and the opportunity.
Nicole says
This is an amazing opportunity!! You guys are the best.
Melaya Rose says
Winning this opportunity would be gaining a gift you cherish for life.
This is exactly what I need right now.
Thanks for all this great support One Stop provides on this writing journey.
Julee Nicklaus says
Here you go, “any comment”. Pick me. Pick me.
Susan Sams Baggott says
Awesome, I just finished updating the beginning of my novel!
Elli Comeau says
What an amazing give-away. And I happen to know Stuart. Thank you for your generosity!
Greta Gize says
I’m entering! And all set with 20 pages and a synopsis. Thank you for the opportunity.
Michael Lantrip says
Perfect. And on my birthday, too. (No, really. Not a trick).
Claudine says
Sounds like a great opportunity!
Dedra Davis says
I won in 2022, a first page, but wanted to try again because this is the first twenty pages. Thank you again for this blog! I look forward to it daily!
Ian says
Hello Stuart, thanks for the opportunity.
Patrick McGann says
Thanks so much for doing this on a regular basis! I welcome the opportunity!
Beverley Burgess Bell says
Would love to win. Thanks so much. Bev Bell
Bethany Swafford says
Twenty pages? That’s very generous! Sounds like fun.
Jacquolyn McMurray says
I love that you offer this opportunity. Thanks!
Jackie Layton says
What an amazing opportunity. Thanks!
Kate Zerrenner says
Thank you for doing this!
Patricia Nesbitt says
Thank you for offering this opportunity to writers. Best wishes to all who are chosen.
Catherine Misener says
Not sure if I can enter as I recently won one of your First Pages Contest (and that was amazing). But….if we can still enter, consider this my way of saying I’d love to win a look at my first twenty pages and synopsis. My manuscript is a work of speculative fiction.
Jessica Walters says
Hello! would love to win this fab opportunity!
Paula Cappa says
I love these offers. I have a supernatural fantasy novel and completing my final line edits and ready. I’m in!!
Mary S Luce says
This would really help me right now. Thanks for the opportunity.
Yoneta says
Super cool, would love to win! 🙂
Jan Sikes says
I always get excited when these come around, especially when I’ve started a new WIP! I would LOVE for Stuart to give his feedback! Thank you for the opportunity!
Kelly says
What a great opportunity! Thank you!
Jessica Swafford says
Sounds great, just what my first 20 pages needs. Thank you for the opportunity!
Chris Garcia-Halenar says
This is great, Mindy.
Is there anything you can’t do?
Alex Dowda says
Hello! This is very exciting, good luck to everyone who enters!
Lynne Clark says
so exciting! 20 whole pages! I do hope get through, I’ve been working hard on my work and I have brand new front pages!
Glenda Warburton says
Thank you for an amazing opportunity to get direction from Page One!
Amanda I says
Fantastic opportunity 😊🙏 Thanks!
V.M. Sang says
Wonderful opportunity for a professional critique. Thanks.
Bob Miller says
Hello, Mindy. Thanks for this opportunity!
Lucia says
Good day! I would love a critique please. Thank you!
Susan Policoff says
Great contest. Good luck to everyone.